• Should I Let My Sister Take Back the Daughter I’ve Raised for Seven Years?

    I don’t want to let go

    When her younger sister’s addiction left her unable to care for her baby, Peace* (42) stepped in and raised  her niece as her own. Now, seven years later, her sister wants her daughter back. Peace is torn between letting go of the child she’s cared for all these years and preserving her relationship with her sister. What would you do in her shoes?

    My youngest sibling, Elizabeth* (32), has struggled with addiction for years. 

    I first suspected something was wrong  during Christmas celebrations in 2014, when I visited my parents. Elizabeth  had just finished university, and we were sharing a room during the holidays. One evening, I noticed an odd substance tucked away among her belongings. It had an unusual smell, so I asked her about it, but she denied that it was drugs. I didn’t think much of the incident until my parents started complaining about her behaviour after she got her first job in Kano. That’s when things began to spiral.

    Elizabeth stopped coming home and eventually cut off contact with my parents and siblings. When my mother finally visited her in Kano, she found her in a terrible state. Elizabeth was clearly under the influence of drugs and seemed like a different person.

    She eventually lost her job and returned to Ilorin, but by then, her behaviour had changed significantly. She was often disoriented, and my parents could hardly trust her alone. They also caught her smoking several times.

    Get More Zikoko Goodness in Your Mail

    Subscribe to our newsletters and never miss any of the action

    We enrolled her in a faith-based rehabilitation programme, hoping she would get better, but she kept running away from home to places where she could continue using drugs. We’d find her, bring her back, and then she’d disappear again, sometimes for months. It became an exhausting cycle, especially for my aging parents.

    So when Elizabeth became pregnant in 2019, we worried about how she would cope. Her addiction hadn’t improved, and we were afraid  she might disappear again or put the baby’s life at risk. Towards the end of her pregnancy, she moved in with me so I could keep an eye on her until she gave birth.

    In November 2019, she gave birth to a baby girl, Praise*. I hoped becoming a mother would encourage her to turn her life around, but she disappeared again in the thick of COVID, just a few months after the birth. We knew very little about the child’s father, so my parents took over her care.

    It was a tough responsibility, especially because of my mother’s poor eyesight. As Elizabeth’s older sister, I felt obligated to step in. I had teenage children and was in a better position to give Praise the care and attention she needed.

    I took Praise to Abuja, where I live, and have provided for her ever since. I’ve singlehandedly paid  her school fees and handled all her needs. She’s a cheerful, bubbly child who reminds me of the person Elizabeth was before addiction took over her life. Over time, we grew so close that she started calling me Mummy, and I’ve come to see her as my own daughter. She’s never felt like a burden to me.

    In 2023, my twins moved to Europe for their education, leaving Praise and me at home with my husband.  Then, in 2024, I lost him to cancer. It was tough, but having Praise around made it easier to cope with the loneliness of being widowed. She kept me company and made me laugh. Caring for her gave me something to do every day.

    Meanwhile, Elizabeth’s repeated relapses had worn down my patience. At one point, we arranged mentorship sessions for her with a well-known female pastor in the hope that the guidance would help her. But after one session, Elizabeth stole the pastor’s phone and disappeared. We eventually discovered that she’d exchanged it for drugs. I had to pay for the replacement phone since my parents couldn’t afford it. I was so upset that I stopped involving myself in her struggles.

    However, Elizabeth continued to battle her addiction. In 2024, she had a near-fatal overdose and nearly lost her life. She eventually moved back in with my parents for good, and when we saw her determination to seek help, my siblings and I pooled resources to pay for her rehabilitation. 

    Her recovery has been encouraging. Last year, she got a teaching job and started helping my mother with her business. I’m genuinely happy to see her gradually rebuilding her life.

    But that progress came with a difficult conversation. When I called Elizabeth to congratulate her on getting a job, she told me she wanted to take Praise into her custody. I was taken aback. I couldn’t understand why she wanted to disrupt the only life Praise had known, especially when she was still rebuilding her own. Elizabeth however insisted that she had the right to have her daughter back.

    I raised my concerns with my parents, and they understood where I was coming from. To avoid an outright disagreement, they suggested that Praise spend the Christmas holidays with them. We hoped the visit would help her gradually adjust to spending more time with her biological mother before any permanent change.

    When Praise returned, I asked how she’d found the visit. She said she’d enjoyed spending time with her mum, but missed me and the environment she was used to. She also found my parents quite strict and wasn’t too comfortable staying with them.

    Beyond my attachment to Praise, I’m concerned about whether Elizabeth is ready to take on the responsibility of raising a child. Praise was only about eight months old when Elizabeth left her in our care, so she has never really had to raise her. I know she’s making progress, but I’m still afraid of the possibility of another relapse and don’t want Praise caught up in the consequences.

    At first, I used Praise’s school calendar to postpone the decision. I told Elizabeth that she should finish the school year before moving in with her.  But September came and went, and I was still reluctant to let her go. Elizabeth pressured me to send her, but  my parents eventually intervened again, insisting that Praise should remain with me at least until the Christmas holidays.

    Elizabeth has since distanced herself, but I only became concerned when Praise told me that Elizabeth had called her using her teacher’s phone number at school. I’m worried she might be saying things that could confuse Praise.

    Now that December is approaching, I’m becoming even more reluctant to let Praise visit her mother. I’m afraid that if she goes, Elizabeth might refuse to let her return, and I may never get her back. I’ve even considered cancelling the visit altogether.

    I know Elizabeth is Praise’s biological mother and I understand that she wants to raise her daughter. But I’ve raised this child since she was a baby. I don’t know the right thing to do. I love Praise, and the thought of losing her after all these years is painful. But I also don’t want my personal attachment to get in the way of what’s best for her. What would you do if you were in my shoes?


    Read Next: I Betrayed My Brother To Protect His Girlfriend. I’d Do It Again

    About the Authors

More By This Author

Zikoko amplifies African youth culture by curating and creating smart and joyful content for young Africans and the world.