From messy love triangles and shocking recouplings to enough gaslighting to last a lifetime, Love Island USA season 8 has delivered nonstop drama. Naturally, Nigerians have opinions. We asked some viewers to share their hottest takes on the season, and they didn’t hold back. 

“Female friendship is the star of the show” —Kemi* 29

Love Island has convinced me that female friendships matter more than romantic relationships. F*ck the boys.

The women have built a community. Even when Melanie and Aniya liked the same man, they still looked out for each other. During Casa Amor time, they actually got to know the new boys before deciding there was a connection. Meanwhile, the men were quick to flirt and trash-talk the women they’d left behind.

Watching the girls celebrate each other and show up for one another made me realise how much we centre romance, even though friendships are often the relationships that carry us through our hardest moments. 

“Leave when they disrespect you” —Hadiza*, 26

Watching Melanie and Sincere reminded me why you should leave the first time someone disrespects you. They weren’t exclusive, so I don’t blame him for exploring other connections. The problem was the lies.

He told Melanie she was the only one while kissing other girls and making them the same promises. Every step of the way, he had the chance to be honest. Instead,  he kept everyone around by telling them what they wanted to hear.

Melanie kept giving him the benefit of the doubt. She even passed up another connection because she trusted him. By the time she found out the truth, she was physically shaking.

That’s why I don’t believe in waiting for someone to change. Every extra chance you give someone who’s already shown you who they are only makes the heartbreak worse.

“The producers have an agenda” —Fatima*, 28

The producers care more about drama than helping people find love.

Take Melanie and Sincere. Sincere is responsible for his behaviour, but the producers kept throwing things at Melanie just to get a reaction out of her. It felt like they wanted her to crash out for a viral moment,  not because they wanted her to know the truth. 

The show is supposed to be about finding love, but healthy couples barely get any attention because they’re “boring”. Instead, the people causing the most chaos get rewarded.

“The men are red-pilled” —Jessica*, 25

Nigerian men on X need to stop defending KC. Nobody is angry that he explored other connections. That’s the whole point of Love Island. People are upset because of how he treated the women he was coupled up with. He lied and disrespected them for no reason.

The most alarming part has been watching so many men excuse the guys’ behaviour. Zach and KC’s views on women sound exactly like the kind of red pill content that’s become popular in the US. I fear we’re slowly importing that mindset into Nigeria and treating manipulation like it’s just another dating strategy. 

“Corbin is racist” —Joshua* 31

I don’t think Corbin likes or supports Black women. The pattern is hard to ignore. 

Consider how he interacted with Aniya and Trinity compared to the other girls. He was eager to kiss Kayda and Melanie, but the only women he kept at arm’s length were the two Black women, despite seeming to have good connections with both of them.

To make things worse, his ex recently claimed on a live stream that he’s racist towards Black women. Watching him in the villa proves her point.

“Sincere isn’t boyfriend material” —Adam*, 26

The girls need to realise Sincere is perfect for a sneaky link, not a boyfriend. 

He’s anything but sincere. He’s a serial liar who tells every woman exactly what she wants to hear. Every time he messes around with someone new, he rewrites the story before taking it back to the girl he’s coupled up with.

When he kissed Sol, he told Melanie she’d initiated it, even though he leaned in first. Then he’d tell Sol he wanted to focus on her, only to turn around and tell Melanie he missed her and didn’t want things to end.

He doesn’t have a type. He just says whatever keeps his options open. The girls need to clock that and leave him alone.

“Women need to trust their intuition more” —Princess* 24

Women need to trust their intuition more. Aniya always seemed unsure about KC. You could tell she never fully relaxed around him, but she convinced herself to give him a chance because everyone else thought they were a good match.

Then the new bombshell arrived, and her body language changed immediately. She was happier and more affectionate without forcing it. KC couldn’t understand why she’d never been that way with him, but it’s clear she never felt safe with him. 

Too many women ignore their instincts because they don’t want to seem difficult or picky. But body language rarely lies.

“KC shouldn’t be on the show” —Osas*, 23

KC should’ve been dumped the moment nobody stepped to his door. That moment influenced his entire game. He expected someone to choose him. When nobody did, he settled with Aniya because it guaranteed him a place in the villa.

He fooled me with the nice guy act.  That’s why the KC we met in the first week is nothing like the KC we’re seeing now. He’s a scammer and should be voted out as soon as possible.

“Titi is a snake” —Chioma* 27

Titi isn’t a girl’s girl. She’s playing the long game in the villa.

She knows she needs the girls on her side, but she also can’t afford to lose KC. So she’s constantly walking the line,  defending the girls just enough to protect her image while making sure KC never takes the full heat.

I don’t think she’s clueless at all. I think she’s one of the most strategic people this season. I hope everyone catches unto her soon. 

Read Next: Married Nigerians on Staying After Their Partner Cheated